We tested astrology on 56,000 lives. One rule held.

I am a math person, so I did not want a nice story. I wanted a test. We took 56,537 birth charts with a birth time, their dated life events, and ran 130 tests written down before looking at any result. Most classic claims did not hold. One timing rule did, twice.

The experiment, step by step

  1. 1

    56,537

    Birth charts

    with a birth time; 46,719 rated AA or A

  2. 2

    130

    Rules written first

    from Brennan, Surtees, Demetra George, before any result

  3. 3

    100

    Discovery

    best-documented award winners: 3 leads at x1.7

  4. 4

    781

    Confirmation

    new people, never used: only one lead holds

  5. 5

    x1.3

    Result

    awards in years whose lord sits in the 10th (p = 0.005)

Chance is computed person by person, over their own adult life.

123456789101112
Each birthday, the year moves one house on. The year's lord is the ruler of that sign. When that planet sits in your 10th house, the year leans to recognition.

The numbers

Awards in those years Expected by chance

First 100 people

13%
7.2%

781 new people

11%
8.7%

With the firdaria too (781 new people)

7.2%
5%

The rule that held

Awards come more often in a year whose lord sits in the 10th house of the birth chart.

The year's lord comes from annual profections: at each birthday the year moves one house on, and the ruler of that sign leads the year. When that planet sits in your 10th house, the house of public life, the year leans to recognition.

First test, 100 well-documented award winners: 13% of their awards fell in those years, against 7.2% expected by chance. Then the real test, on 781 other people we had never used: 11.0% against 8.7% (p = 0.005). In plain words: about 30% more often than an ordinary year. It raises the odds, it does not guarantee anything.

Stronger when two techniques agree

When the firdaria, the Persian time lords, also point to the 10th house in that same year, the share rises again: 7.2% against 5.0% expected on the 781 new people (x1.4, p = 0.0014). Firdaria alone shows nothing. It is the agreement that counts, which is exactly how astrologers work.

Three real examples where profection, firdaria and zodiacal releasing all point to the 10th on the day: Venus Williams wins Wimbledon on 8 July 2000, Gaspard Ulliel receives the César for best actor on 24 February 2017, Sœur Emmanuelle is made Grand Officer of the Légion d'honneur on 31 January 2008.

What did not hold

Sun signs by profession: tiny effects only. Baseball players are more often Leo, but that comes from the US league cut-off date, not the sky.

The Mars effect of Gauquelin for athletes: 17.8% against 17.1% expected. Nothing.

Children in a 5th house year: it is only age. Everyone's year reaches the 5th house at 28, the most common age for a first child.

Saturn and Jupiter returns, solar arcs, zodiacal releasing alone: no more events than on dates shifted by a few years in the same life.

The scorecard

  • Held

    Lord of the year in the 10th, awards

    11.0% vs 8.7% on 781 new people

  • Held

    Same, with the firdaria agreeing

    7.2% vs 5.0% (x1.4)

  • Did not hold

    Sun sign by profession

    tiny effects; baseball Leos = US league cut-off

  • Did not hold

    Gauquelin Mars effect, athletes

    17.8% vs 17.1% expected

  • Did not hold

    Children in a 5th house year

    only age: everyone reaches the 5th at 28

  • Did not hold

    Divorce with solar return Ascendant in the 7th

    7.0% vs 7.9% on 285 new people

  • Did not hold

    Zodiacal releasing alone

    7.0% vs 8.2% on 781 new people

  • Did not hold

    Returns and solar arcs alone

    same as dates shifted by a few years

How we tested, honestly

Rules were written down before looking, with their source (Chris Brennan, Kelly Surtees, Demetra George). Chance is computed person by person, over the days of their own adult life, so rare events like a wedding or an award are fairly counted. A rule found on the first group only counts if it holds again on people never used. We also shuffled ages between people to rule out an age effect.

Limits: these are famous people with public biographies, so some events are missing. Only birth times rated AA or A were used. One rule out of many held, and the effect is modest. That is what real data looks like.

Find your own lord of the year

Your profection year, its lord, and where it sits in your birth chart, in three steps.

Keep reading

Questions

Does predictive astrology work?

Most single rules we tested did not beat chance. One did, twice: awards come about 30% more often in years whose lord sits in the 10th house, and a bit more when the firdaria agree. Timing techniques work best combined, read in one birth chart.

What is the lord of the year?

In annual profections, each year of life activates one house, in order from the Ascendant. The planet that rules that house's sign is the lord of the year.

How many birth charts were tested?

56,537 birth charts with a birth time, 46,719 of them rated AA or A (birth certificate or the person's own words). The award rule was tested on 881 award winners.

How can I find my own years?

Find your profection year and its lord, then look where that planet sits in your birth chart. The profections guide shows how, step by step.

Take the lab in your pocket.

Know your best days before they arrive. Check them every morning, and practice on the lives of the stars.

New on Google Play

MandalaYour Human Design, in short lessons
LuopanChinese astrology and feng shui, day by day

The astrology practice playground.

Here you learn by doing. Try each technique on a real birth chart, get corrected on the spot, and come back to play. Free to start.